I was the smartest girl in the school until I was 8. Then came Cayre. She read faster than me (impossible). She wrote stronger than me (unthinkable). She even excelled in art class, where I unsteadily reigned as the finger paint princess. My one consolation was that she was not invited to make up Paula Abdul dances at recess, and I was the star.
It goes without saying, we never spoke.
Then one day, our names were up on the blackboard. “We must be in trouble,” I told her. She nodded, alarmed. We both tugged our braids; hers were long and black, Indian-princess style and slapping down her back. Mine were blonde and clumped into a bun, “like a movie star,” I had instructed my mother that morning. They both got pulled by boys.
“You’ve been picked,” said The Teacher, “to represent our class at the school reading show. You’ll read a story. Together.”
We both winced; our first act of “together,” but The Teacher didn’t see.
That weekend I went to her house. We were supposed to pick a chapter of a book to read aloud to the school. I wanted Dracula. She wanted Little House on the Prarie. We both wanted, desperately, to quit.
“Let’s go outside,” she said, and of course I was an indoor girl. She handed me a pair of wellies.
“I am not wearing those,” I growled. “Those are ugly.”
“Those,” she shot back, “Are the only thing that keep you dry in the swamp.”
Swamp? Whoa. The only swamp I knew about was in Fraggle Rock.
“It’s behind our house,” she explained, “and I walk in it all the time. You’ll come, unless of course, you’re scared.”
“What I’m scared of,” I snapped back, “Is someone seeing me in those ugly boots.”
But really, the swamp was terrifying. It was huge, which was scary. It was smelly, which was frightful. But the real terror came from its glisten, a slimy sheen of frog backs and fly wings and gunk that slicked the top like germ gloss. Gross.
“Let’s go,” said Cayre, a military command. She marched into the swamp like a duckling and I tried to follow her and I failed. Actually, I flailed. Actually, I fell.
The swamp was unexpectedly freezing, an ice pack of dead grass and chilled slime and cold slugs. My pink dress turned pitch purple and my lungs got shrill from screaming.
Cayre calmly dragged me up, and dragged me out, and dragged me to her parent’s bathtub, where I was drenched in steaming water and handed a fresh pair of pajamas.
“You only wear pink,” she explained, “and these are the only pink things I have… I know,” she groaned, “they’re ugly.”
That’s when I finally stopped crying.
“They are ugly,” I nodded. “They’re terrible.”
“See?” she smiled. “We agree on something. Finally.”
Last year, I bought some Hunter wellies from Scotland. They are not pretty. They are not pink. They are easily my favorite shoes.
[ISABELLE McNALLY - AM I THE IMAGINARY SOCIALITE?]